Benito Skinner, widely recognized for his viral internet persona as Benny Drama, is stepping into the world of television with his new semi-autobiographical comedy series, Overcompensating. In an a first look, Skinner, who created, wrote, and executive produced the series, shares a story of self-discovery, friendship, and the complexities of college life through the eyes of his character, Benny.
The series is set in a college environment and follows Benny, a closeted former football player and homecoming king, as he navigates his way through the ups and downs of student life. The show dives deep into the trials of trying to fit into different social circles, all while struggling with his own identity. Benny forms an unexpected and fast friendship with Carmen, a fellow student played by Wally Baram, who is an outsider desperately trying to fit in at any cost. Together, they tackle the messiness of college life, with its “horrible hookups, flavored vodka, and fake IDs,” all while attempting to find themselves in the process.
— Prime Video (@PrimeVideo) March 12, 2025
According to Skinner, Overcompensating is more than just a comedy about college—it is a dramedy that delves into the lengths people go to overcompensate for their insecurities while on the path of self-discovery. “I think we all have moments in our lives where we try to pretend to be someone we’re not, especially in college,” Skinner said. “This series explores the tension between the image we want to project and the person we’re really trying to figure out how to be.”
Skinner portrays Benny in the series, and his personal experiences as a college student are reflected in the character. Benny’s journey of navigating the complexities of identity and acceptance will resonate with viewers who have experienced the pressures of fitting into certain social molds or reconciling their public persona with their true selves.
The show is also notable for its star-studded cast, which includes both seasoned actors and rising talents. Overcompensating features Kyle MacLachlan and Connie Britton as Benny’s on-screen parents, adding star power to the show’s dynamic. Both actors, known for their iconic roles in Twin Peaks and Friday Night Lights, respectively, bring depth and nuance to their roles. MacLachlan’s character, John, and Britton’s character, Kathryn, serve as loving yet flawed figures in Benny’s life who offer guidance, but also embody the pressures and expectations that many college students feel from their families.
Rish Shah, a series regular, plays Benny’s best friend, Miles, who helps him navigate the chaotic world of college. Miles and Benny’s friendship is at the heart of the show, with both characters offering each other support as they try to figure out who they are in the face of societal expectations. The bond between Benny and Carmen, as well as Benny’s relationship with his older sister (played by Mary Beth Barone of Black Mirror), will also be central to the show’s exploration of identity and self-acceptance.
Joining the ensemble cast in guest roles are Kaia Gerber, Owen Thiele, and Grammy-winning pop star Charli XCX, who also serves as the executive music producer for the series. Charli XCX’s involvement adds a unique layer to the project, bringing her pop expertise to the music-driven moments within Overcompensating. As an executive music producer, she is helping to shape the show’s musical landscape and elevate the emotional beats with a carefully curated soundtrack that speaks to the themes of the show.
The collaboration between Skinner and Charli XCX isn’t the only exciting partnership for the project. Overcompensating is being produced by A24, a production company known for its work on critically acclaimed projects such as Lady Bird and Euphoria. In addition, Jonah Hill serves as an executive producer through his production company, Strong Baby, further elevating the show’s pedigree.
Skinner’s rise to fame through his Benny Drama persona on social media has allowed him to develop a unique voice in the entertainment industry. His viral celebrity impressions and satirical skits, which often parody popular culture and Hollywood figures, garnered widespread attention and caught the eye of the stars he mimicked. Skinner’s collaborations with A-list celebrities, such as Drew Barrymore, Kourtney Kardashian, and Jennifer Aniston, have made him a household name. With Overcompensating, Skinner transitions from internet sensation to a full-fledged television creator, drawing from his own experiences while creating an entertaining narrative about self-exploration and the awkwardness of adolescence.
Skinner has expressed excitement about bringing Overcompensating to a wider audience, stating, “It’s a dream come true to be able to create a show that combines my love for humor, personal storytelling, and the awkwardness of growing up. College is such a weird, confusing time, and I’m excited to share a piece of that experience with people.”
All episodes of Overcompensating are set to drop on Prime Video on May 15, giving audiences the chance to binge-watch the entire season in one go. Fans can expect a mix of humor, heart, and authentic moments that tackle real-life issues with a comedic lens. The show promises to explore the absurdity of college culture while simultaneously offering a relatable, heartfelt exploration of identity and self-acceptance.
With its unique blend of comedy, drama, and musical elements, Overcompensating is shaping up to be a must-watch for fans of Skinner’s work, as well as those who enjoy coming-of-age stories with an edgy twist. The series is sure to resonate with anyone who has ever struggled with fitting in, overcompensated in the face of insecurity, or tried to find themselves amidst the chaos of college life.
As the countdown to its May release begins, Overcompensating is already generating buzz as one of the most anticipated shows of 2025. With a talented cast, a unique premise, and a creative team led by Benito Skinner, the series is poised to be a breakout hit when it premieres on Prime Video.
